Ok, so I Tried to do a high poly roof, then Retopologize it. I think it turned out pretty well. Although the poly count came out higher than the one with duplicated Shingles. They both need a little bit of work. Personally I enjoy the previous one, but I'm going to rework this one before i give up and go back to the original shingled one. There some obvious changes that need to be made, but I think at this point I'm going to give it a rest.